55 条评论
- aaddrick 12小时前Hey!
I manage the unofficial build at https://github.com/aaddrick/claude-desktop-debian
Debian is in the name, but scope has grown to all backends, compositors, etc.
The main reason must companies don't publish Linux electron apps is fragmentation. If you're doing anything more than rendering a webpage as an app, it starts to get complicated. I've got a bank of VM's setup for testing, and I still need it up.
- Retr0id 13小时前If only Anthropic had some kind of automated tool that was good at porting software
- shepherdjerred 10小时前Even if you can create infinite software you still have to be very intentional about what you’re choosing to work on.
There’s still a cost to testing, support, planning, etc even if coding is now “free”
- mmcnl 9小时前Anthropic claims 8-fold productivity increase since 2025. If even that isn't enough to enable support for Linux, I don't know what it is.
- shepherdjerred 7小时前I didn't say that they _couldn't_, but it clearly isn't a priority for them. They still have the same opportunity cost any other engineering team faces.
They can work on feature X or feature Y -- which is the better choice?
Apparently they don't think Linux support is significant. I doubt the lack of support is due to technical constraints.
- kdnvk 1小时前They explicitly did not claim this in the blog post
- pixl97 7小时前[flagged]
- trumpdong 10小时前If only Anthropic had some kind of automated testing, support, planning machine.
- shepherdjerred 7小时前You wouldn't run an engineering company with 500 engineers reporting directly to the CEO.
AI doesn't solve this. You need humans who can understand and verify what is being made.
- ameliaquining 12小时前It doesn't sound like that's the bottleneck.
- cookiengineer 12小时前You forgot the *allegedly in there.
- scrollop 9小时前Imagine if cutting edge AI companies could decide to using their world best AI to
1) Develop software for linux
2) Provide decent support
- gessha 47分钟前Still not enough to establish the year of Linux on the desktop.
- zombot 9小时前If there were any truth to the marketing stories that say they have such a thing, then they could indeed.
- kskdkwjdkwkkds 8小时前It’s almost as if this whole productivity increase promised by AI is just marketing spiel, huh? Crazy.
- Lionga 13小时前Use the existing Slop they have that needs 1GB of Ram for a simple Terminal app to create an even more slopped Linux app... If only they had any devs at their 500K and way up pay package that could actually write a simple app, that you know does not suck.
- lioeters 11小时前Those highly paid human devs are hard at work on the Torment Nexus, which is their priority of course, you don't want China to win do you?
- robby_w_g 10小时前Torment doomers claim that the commodification of humanity’s suffering will usher in a dark age, but quarterly earnings have never been higher. I trust that Death Star Inc has humanity’s best interests at heart.
- delduca 12小时前You’re asking too much.
- smrtinsert 11小时前Sorry that's not the use case anymore its about (checks notes) "forward deployed engineers", yep that's it. Go build!
- supriyo-biswas 8小时前TBH I don't get the narrative there either. Earlier it was about how regular people can now build many types of software for themselves (and btw, I agree with this), but somehow the narrative has shifted to something like "regular software engineers would work with the customer to develop applications", which makes a lot less sense.
- braiamp 3小时前I find interesting that so many people say that this is a hard problem, while Discord puts this nugget:
> Are you a Linux user? If so, are you sick of that lovely modal we made to tell you that there’s an update you need to go manually install? IF SO, boy do I have good news for you. We’ve ported our Rust-based updater to Linux, allowing Linux to update itself just like on Windows. Additionally, we now support .rpm and .pkg.tar.zst package formats for installation.
They have more challenging clients: have to deal with screencapture, audio capture, audio routing, meanwhile supporting 3 different package repositories. You just have to accept that you should be updating your build/runtime dependencies with each version as long as they fix your underlying problems. Having a single binary that you release and works, implies that you are shipping every library your binary depends on. Windows takes care of that with winsxs, Linux asks you to do it yourself.
- shanewei 13小时前What do you miss from the Desktop app that the CLI doesn’t cover? I’m mostly on Linux too and have just been using the CLI, so I’m curious.
- SyneRyder 13小时前I don't think the CLI offers daily routines under the Anthropic subscription anymore?
There's also the cross conversation memory search, which uses a different conversation dataset (the Claude Web / Claude.AI conversations) than Claude Code does. I'm not even sure Claude Code does cross conversation search?
The Desktop interface also presents Markdown as formatted text and presents artifacts (especially interactive ones) better than the CLI can.
All that said - I actually use the CLI for nearly everything (even on Windows). Rather than use Claude Desktop for daily "routines" that are capped at 15 total cron-jobs and use extra usage credits, I think I'll continue building my own minimal harness and move my routines to models from other providers.
- filoleg 12小时前> I don't think the CLI offers daily routines under the Anthropic subscription anymore?
It (Claude Code) does, I discovered it by accident recently, having never used daily routines before. Haven't touched Claude Desktop at all, outside of playing with it for 30 mins or so months ago.
TLDR: I used Claude Code to build a command that scrapes job postings from a few employers I am interested in (it is a bit more complicated than that, but that's the gist). At the end CC asked me "do you want me to re-run it daily?" I said yes, and it generated a daily routine and gave me a URL to my anthropic account page where I can see all my daily routines.
There, it says that I am currently using up 1 out of 15 "free" daily routines that come with my personal subscription, and I would have to pay extra if I want to have more than 15 active at a time (I assume by switching to per-token pricing for anything beyond 15, but not sure).
- Avicebron 12小时前> All that said - I actually use the CLI for nearly everything (even on Windows).
I also haven't touched routines, but I use cc to write automation tasks that will integrate a model when I need an inference layer. Which I also did before routines..
Have people actually been using routines effectively?
- tstrimple 12小时前> There's also the cross conversation memory search, which uses a different conversation dataset (the Claude Web / Claude.AI conversations) than Claude Code does. I'm not even sure Claude Code does cross conversation search?
This is one of the first things I “fixed” with skills and hooks. I index every conversation in SQLite and have a skill which knows what to do when I ask it to search the index. I had to avoid the word memory because it’s too tied up in other parts of the context. It even indexes across my different machines. I set this up because I have terrible context discipline. I’ll go off on a tangent in one context and start planning and sometimes implementing something based on that thread which really deserves its own context. Afterward I can create the new context and move relevant bits to it, but I’d lose that initial starting conversation which inherently has more data than the summary in the new context.
I also use a few different related contexts. One where I’m building a game engine in zig and another talking about game ideas. There’s a lot of back and forth going on there which needs some shared context. I solve this with a combination of Claude.md references and that searchable session index.
Everything I do with scheduled tasks are just wired up with systemd and simple scripts. No LLM in the critical execution path. Again a skill tells CC how I manage those scheduled things so I just have to say something like “run this every day at midnight” and CC has reliably taken care of the rest.
- outofpaper 9小时前Why not just allow it to grep ~/.claude
- shanewei 2小时前[dead]
- Recursing 13小时前1. Same experience as my non-Linux coworkers, so we can share learnings and processes
2. Scheduled tasks that run locally ( https://support.claude.com/en/articles/13854387-schedule-rec... ) importantly different from Claude Code routines
3. Multiple projects/isolated memories in the same folder
4. Better UI
- nozzlegear 12小时前> Scheduled tasks that run locally ( https://support.claude.com/en/articles/13854387-schedule-rec... ) importantly different from Claude Code routines
What do people do with these? I don't use Claude but when I did I couldn't think of anything useful to do with the routines. I'm probably not being imaginative enough.
- jeroenhd 9小时前At work, I have my Claude set up to go through the issue tracker, source control, dashboards, team Slack channels, calendar appointments, and have it look for things like upcoming scheduling issues and deadlines that might get tough. A lot of those services need a corporate VPN or access to my local machine for the LLM to get the information right.
Nothing I can't do myself (and generally I do keep an eye on that sort of thing), but it did catch a holiday for my foreign team members that seemed to have gone unnoticed, and remarked about a status mismatch between Jira and source control that made the dashboard misrepresent progress. It's not much, but it's an extra little check that works quite well.
Another trick I'm experimenting with is having Claude rebase my open PRs waiting for review every day, and auto-solving conflicts when they arise. I don't trust it enough to let it push code to the repository, but I think I have the prompt set up in such a way that I might soon start using it.
- e12e 8小时前While not trying to recreate the infamous dropbox comment - if you already have Claude code, are on Linux - can't Claude write a cronjob/systemd task that invokes itself for you?
- jeroenhd 8小时前I could write a program that does this of course, but interpreting the current state of Slack threads is not something a Python script will be able to do without involving another LLM. I automated and script what I need or want to automate and script already, but for things like this where understanding of language is useful, I leave it to the slop machine.
Things like "this is a holiday in country X but only for people living in province Y except for in town Z" are massive pain to script. Plus, if the issue tracker and source control automation were working correctly, I wouldn't need to read the status of both to get a good understanding of the situation. Any time scripting there should probably be spent (by someone else) on fixing the problem in the first place.
When Claude eventually doubles or triples the token cost to stop hemorrhaging money, I'm going to lose these scripts and I won't be upset about it in the least. But until then, my "somewhat understanding of context" script-but-not-really setup is proving quite useful.
- e12e 7小时前I meant more like:
(Courtesy of Gemini, not Claude code, as I'm on my phone).0 8 * * 1-5 claude -p "Fetch my unread emails from the last 24 hours, identify urgent items, and provide a bulleted summary." >> ~/desktop/daily_email_summary.txtNow, obviously - you might want something a little more elegant; but my point was that if you already grant Claude tool access to your email, slack etc - then it should be trivial to wrap it in a script, and run that from Cron.
I wouldn't do that; I don't trust Claude code with access to my mail (nor would I trust Claude desktop - but I don't use it anyway).
But, if you do trust Claude to read your slack and email, I don't see why Claude code couldn't do this for you almost out of the box?
- thewebguyd 9小时前Cowork is pretty useful for non-technical folk for things you'd traditionally just write a quick little bash or python script for (which really, is what Cowork is doing behind the scenes anyway).
I've gotten good results using it at work for keeping track of expense receipts. I dump them into an "Inbox" folder and Claude will OCR them, convert any images to PDF, rename, and move them into year/month/date folders and classify them (cost centers, based on a mapping and examples I gave it). This runs daily, checking the Inbox directory for new items.
My next step is getting it to pull them from my email automatically for me as well, or from a specific alias so when I take a pic of a receipt on the go I can just email it and have Claude rename and organize it for me, then it all gets sent off to AP at the end of the month.
Non technical knowledge workers have all kinds of little admin tasks like that which Cowork can do for them, where previously they lacked the skills or will to just learn some python and script it themselves.
- baq 12小时前I’d like the thing to read my mail twice a day and tell me if I missed something important.
Haven’t set it up because I’m horrified by the thought of it reading my mail. Doubly so if it decides to do anything other than telling me if I missed something important.
- Recursing 12小时前Some good ideas here: https://posthog.com/blog/making-claude-cowork-actually-usefu...
- deskamess 8小时前> Multiple projects/isolated memories in the same folder
I cannot stand this and do not know how to start a new project/session in a new folder. Even if I select a new folder in the UI when typing the first prompt of a new session, it keeps going back to the first folder I created. For this reason alone I am thinking of going to the CLI. But if anyone has any answers, I am all ears.
- giancarlostoro 4小时前For one thing, the Desktop app lets me control any remote sessions I have open via the Code functionality.
- mobiuscog 5小时前I would like to see the inline images that Claude suddenly tries to show me, until I remind them that I can't see images in the CLI.
Other than that, I am happy with the CLI.
- dahkenangnon 13小时前The CLI is good for coding tasks but for other things non coding related, having the desktop app can be very useful
- davydm 13小时前Mainly: true sandbox separation. I don't want the model having full access to my machine. With a dump format that Claude understands, I'm able to pass only the files I want Claude to see, and he can't break any of them. I don't care about setting up access lists and so on. I don't trust that the cli product will be properly sanboxed and it's quite clear their software offerings are largely aigen code, and I catch bugs from Claude every day. I also get useful stuff, so it's worth it, but definitely not worth it, imo, to grant it any access to my machine.
- mathstuf 13小时前There are a number of utilities for this. I use jai: https://jai.scs.stanford.edu/ but also have seen nono: https://github.com/always-further/nono smolvm: https://github.com/smol-machines/smolvm zerobox https://github.com/afshinm/zerobox and matchlock https://github.com/jingkaihe/matchlock
They all have pros and cons. Pick the one that suits you best. Then you're also agent harness flexible (I use opencode).
- johnsonjo 12小时前As a jai and linux user, myself, looking at nono's os-sandbox (from here [1]) it seems nice too. Thanks for the recommend I was looking for something that might be nice on Mac and nono seems good to recommend to coworkers and the like.
- sophrosyne42 11小时前I would like a solution that was itself not largely written by an AI
- johnsonjo 9小时前Jai is not written by ai, but only its website is. It's written by a Stanford Computer-Science professor with decades of C++ and Unix/linux experience.
> [1]: Was jai written by an AI coding agent? No. While this web site was obviously made by an LLM (ChatGPT read the man page, asked some follow-up questions, and produced a prompt from which claude code built a vitepress site), jai itself was hand implemented by a Stanford computer science professor with decades of C++ and Unix/linux experience. As an experiment, the author did previously try vibe-coding a container, but the results were disastrous and repeatedly put his machine in a state that required a reboot (e.g., recursively changing the attributes of all mounts in the wrong mount namespace). The author does use coding agents to look for bugs, get feedback, and develop tests. However, rest assured that a single human understands every line of C++ in jai.
- WhyNotHugo 13小时前The cli works on regular sandboxes just fine (podman, docker, bwrap, etc).
Sandboxing a GUI is typically more operational overhead than sandboxing a cli (mounting compositor sockets, GPU access, etc).
- johnsonjo 13小时前I've been using jai [1] for sandboxing on linux (although I use opencode and local models and not claude code) and I'm pretty satisfied with it. It comes in three different modes [2]: casual mode, strict mode, and bare mode. Here's some descriptions of each mode:
Casual mode [3]: > Your home directory is mounted as a copy-on-write overlay. The jailed process sees your real files, but writes go to $HOME/.jai/default.changes instead of modifying originals, except in the directory where you ran jai. Your current working directory grants full read/write access to code in the jail (unless suppressed with -D). So files deleted there are really gone. /tmp and /var/tmp are private. The rest of the filesystem is read-only.
Strict mode [4]: > The process runs as the unprivileged jai system user, not as you. Home directory is an empty private directory at $HOME/.jai/<name>.home. Granted directories (via -d or cwd) are exposed with id-mapped mounts — files look like they are owned by jai inside the jail. Because the process has a different UID, it cannot read files outside your home directory that are only accessible to your user — this is where confidentiality comes from.
Bare mode [5]: > Home directory is an empty private directory, like strict mode. But the process runs as your user, not as jai. This means it cannot provide confidentiality — the process can still read any file accessible to your UID outside the home directory.
I've always ran my stuff in casual so far just so my whole computer doesn't get rimraffed :P. but I'm thinking of switching to just strict mode, but haven't really vibe coded in a while so I haven't tried it yet.
[1]: https://jai.scs.stanford.edu/
[2]: https://jai.scs.stanford.edu/modes.html
[3]: https://jai.scs.stanford.edu/modes.html#casual-mode
- mkagenius 11小时前[dead]
- _aavaa_ 13小时前If you don’t trust the CLI version to be properly sandbox d, why would the desktop one be?
- jeena 13小时前I made myself a very simple one from the start when I realized it can access everything on my computer https://git.jeena.net/jeena/agent-container my goal was that it would work transparently and the paths and user, etc. would be just the same as on the host but inside of a docker container.
- notsirius 13小时前does claude desktop actually solve this issue? I’m on mac and use docker sbx to solve this https://docs.docker.com/ai/sandboxes/get-started/
- FergusArgyll 12小时前On Linux you have bubblewrap!
- raverbashing 13小时前Or, what does the Desktop app does that the webpage doesn't do?
- TiredOfLife 7小时前Pasting images
- splwjs 9小时前What's the market for linux users who want an electron app so they can vibecode in a visual studio fork but wont just build it themselves nor do they want to clone and build someone else's repo
- olivierestsage 6小时前No horse in this race because I don’t want a Claude app, but the median Linux user is increasingly just a normal person who doesn’t want spying telemetry or ads or whatever
- iknowstuff 5小时前The median linux pc user is on Chrome OS from their school :p
- giancarlostoro 4小时前I presume they meant if you filter out for Chrome and Android ;)
- giancarlostoro 4小时前Not sure, but I would happily take half the pay of any developer at Anthropic to do that role for them if it gets me Claude Desktop on my Linux box, I do not like third party hacks of Windows Electron apps made to work on Linux, always makes me uncomfortable.
- nullpoint420 8小时前I'm still surprised at how many developers still turn their noses up at using Linux.
Like... You already use Docker and deploy to K8S... On Linux...
- 9dev 8小时前I don’t really care about the OS. I want a beefy laptop with a good keyboard and trackpad, long battery life, and a crisp screen. Preferably very silent, bonus points for a clean design. That’s the value proposition of a MacBook.
- nullpoint420 3小时前I get it. I wish there were more great laptop makers. I had a maxed out 16in M2 Max MacBook Pro, now I have an 15in M3 MBA. I also have a maxed out HP G1A Ultra running Fedora. They’re all excellent.
- make3 4小时前I also care about my desktop supporting consumer electronics without having to waste an afternoon debugging Bluetooth drivers every two weeks
- tokioyoyo 8小时前That’s very much not the same thing though?
- OsrsNeedsf2P 8小时前It kind of is?
Why would you not want your development environment to be as close to your deployment environment as possible? Even MacOS bash commands have hiccups every so often. In my experience working with Linux developers, they seem to know the internals of the servers much better and can optimize/debug prod fast - and this understanding is only compounded with LLMs.
I'm sure many developers would be equally talented at debugging such issues if we deployed on Windows or MacOS, but virtually no one does that.
- madeofpalk 8小时前I do other things on my computer apart from bash.
- giancarlostoro 8小时前Docker was designed for Linux, and on Windows you have to run a VM just to let Docker function.
- preg_match 7小时前[dead]
- greggsy 4小时前Desktop and server are two wildly different support surfaces
- nullpoint420 3小时前Fair, but it’s electron. They can just add a new target and recompile the native libraries they’re using for Linux.
It’s really not that hard.
- neilv 9小时前OK, just please be careful how you frame what you're asking for.
For software development use of Claude, I'd be happy if the `claude` CLI executable does everything I need, within the Linux KVM VM sandboxes I create for the work, without a desktop client. The cleaner and more trustworthy, the better.
Also, for random interactive use of Claude for asking questions, I use it from my host desktop, sandboxed within the Web browser, and I want that to be well-supported. Someone marketing/product person at an AI company will naturally want to dark-pattern push people towards a proprietary desktop client, but that's one corner of abuse potential that we can still keep in check.
For agentic automation of my host desktop things and the things they have access to... no, thank you, the state of the art is not ready for that.
- purpleidea 58分钟前Anthropic is missing the plot by not releasing even the CLI (tui) claude code as open source. On the other hand, Codex is so garbage that as soon as they catch up it will be done for Claude.
- robrain 13小时前Just one-shot vibe it for yourself.
Lame, I know, but you have to entertain yourself sometimes when the only thing anybody talks about here is ruddy spicy autocorrect and self-inflicted job destruction.
- witx 12小时前> self-inflicted job destruction
Glad someone else sees this as well in this crappy website
- taspeotis 12小时前Personally I don’t understand why Claude Code doesn’t have a mode to make text green and characters come down from the top of the screen individually, like in The Matrix.
- gaiagraphia 10小时前Massively bugs me. I have to wear green sunglasses, change the language to Japanese, and turn my monitor sideways to get any real work done nowadays.
- QuantumNoodle 1小时前Goodness, what an unreasonably long description for an issue.
- ameliaquining 1小时前It sounds like a number of less comprehensive issues on this topic were closed without adequate explanation, so the author wanted to be sure to comprehensively explain why the issue was valid and what they were looking for.
- skeledrew 13小时前YES! But also hmm, maybe not. I literally installed the unofficial build[0] a few hours ago, and when I started it and saw a bunch of Electron processes immediately trigger my spawn swarm detector, I just closed it. Don't think I'll ever touch it again.
- himhckr 10小时前Not exactly Claude Desktop but we have something more "generic" that works across multiple OSes (written in Tauri) - Msty Claw [1]. It also comes with a companion E2E encrypted mobile app.
- forsalebypwner 1小时前Thanks, I use DeepSeek and Gemini mostly so I was looking for something that isn't tied to Anthropic. I'm mostly covered by pi.dev but want to try out a GUI to see if they're worth my time. This looks surprisingly feature-complete, too bad it's only "Free for personal use in beta", but I'll definitely give it a spin.
- misterinfo 3小时前Claude Code Prompt: Hey, build me a Claude Desktop for Linux.
- STELLANOVA 7小时前This sounds like a really good test for agentic coding and something Anthropic should seriously consider doing as a proof of Claude Code quality. They could easily have agents built per Linux distribution that will run on every new release and do complete testing and publishing. IF they can successfully do that it would be a nice marketing as well. :)
- reilly3000 1小时前I hope they don’t. I hope somehow inexplicably Goose or something wins.
- prmoustache 4小时前You got to love the irony of seeing hundred of users not being able to actually build a desktop version themselves using the cli agent.
Are LLMs rendering people that useless?
- jjice 4小时前I avoided it after Anthropic's rampage against `claude -p` to stop Openclaw and didn't want to get hit in the crossfire. It was hard to follow their back and forth, but it seems that's done now?
- bnchrch 4小时前Hard for one person to keep up with a product that ships updates multiple times a day.
- hawaiianbrah 4小时前Note “official” in the request… there are unofficial ones.
- nullbio 2小时前OpenAI too. We need Codex app for Linux. For people asking why, the answer is Computer Use.
- btown 7小时前I find Claude Desktop on macOS infinitely better at managing RAM when you have 10+ or more parallel sessions.
(Some for different aspects of full stack features, some for managing specific client situations advised by the codebase and its tools!)
The CLI is not designed to be lightweight, and it’s easy to get into situations where every CLI session consumes multiple GB of memory alone - stack them up and it’s a lot!
And not all terminal GUIs handle multiple tabs well enough to see all sessions at a glance.
So on top of the plugin features, desktop is a really useful thing to have!
- IncreasePosts 7小时前What exactly is taking up so much space? Why does it need anything more than whatever the context is? Isn't it just sending text over an API?
- btown 6小时前So yes, it's a TUI... but it's a TUI rendered by Ink, a React library, with a full JS runtime in the background. The number of re-renders per unit time involved with rerendering a JS implementation of flexbox every new token comes in? That's not a walk in the park for a garbage collector, and a single memory/retention leak can cascade dramatically.
I imagine this is part of the impetus behind the Bun acquisition - they have a deep need to push optimization efforts towards the specific patterns that are most relevant to their use cases. (Which are probably good ones for the broader Bun userbase, to be sure, but relative prioritization is something they now have greater control over.)
- bcherny 7小时前Boris from the team here — we’re looking into it.
- timebeforeland 7小时前Thanks for dropping by. What has been your favorite part of building this tool so far?
- purpleidea 55分钟前[dead]
- xacky 7小时前Might as well say "Adobe, please ship an official creative suite for Linux", and will probably fall on the same deaf ears.
- zoba 12小时前Also can you please make it easy to switch between my work and personal accounts on mobile!
- steezeburger 12小时前Yeah that would be great. I seriously don't understand how a company with this much money doesn't have some of the more basic ux implemented to make it a really great app. Blows my mind.
- ok_major_9889 6小时前I'm building a platform that does just that: https://yeet.cx/docs/
We give Claude full visibility into your Linux machine, with a JS runtime over the top for building tools.
- 999900000999 7小时前Which Linux.
You build it for Ubuntu , people will demand fedora. Build fedora they’ll want Arch.
This is fine for FOSS projects where the community can fork and contribute, but as a company I can imagine tons of support tickets coming from Linux users who’s particularly DE/Distro permutation isn’t working right.
Still. An App Image would be nice
- kobalsky 7小时前So your argument is "if you give a mouse a cookie"? There are plenty of companies and they just throw us a deb and we do the rest.
And even if it were a valid point, why would eye even waste a second of your life argumenting against Linux when it's being asked to a company with a projected 1 trillion dollars IPO.
What's your stake here?
- 999900000999 5小时前The top comment large agrees with me. Your support matrix becomes too vast.
However, I do think an app image or I guess a flatpak would be nice.
- ljlolel 8小时前I made a way to build Swift apps that build on Linux and run and look the same on MacOS https://github.com/Lore-Hex/QuillUI
I know Claude is electron now but if they made it native swift on macos then they could use this
- 0xbadcafebee 6小时前This is like begging Microsoft to port SQL Server to Linux. Anthropic is a proprietary walled garden with poor service trading solely on dominance in a single product field, just like Microsoft with its business tools. Yet people are clamoring to become more dependent on them. Those same complaints you hear from Windows users today? Will be the complaints from Claude users in the future. No choice but to put up with it. What else are you gonna do, learn to use Codex? Your company won't pay for it because the users prefer the one tool they already know how to use. Funny how history repeats itself.
- CAP_NET_ADMIN 4小时前With 10x improvement in per capita code output I'm sure they will get there one day.
- ddosmax556 9小时前Anthropic, if you're reading this: I'm a developer trying to figure out LLMs, I use them 8h per day to do my work. Claude Desktop is a missing piece I don't have access to because I'm only on Linux! I'm happy with a simple AppImage.
- shmoil 12小时前>> Anthropic, please ship an official malware for Linux
Here, fixed it for you.
- predkambrij 13小时前Cowork already boots Ubuntu 22.04 internally on macOS. The Linux execution path exists inside the product. What's missing is a published build.
- kentf 11小时前Our app, Runner: Cowork++
Supports linux :)
- pacificat0r 10小时前How can they? They are busy designing agentic loops. They ship 8x more lines of code!!!
- bytepursuits 11小时前I thought going into ipo they were selling the idea that claude is already build claude.
- JSeiko 12小时前Yes please! I think it's just kinda weird that this hasn't been done yet.
- jeremyjh 12小时前If you feel that strongly about it, why not write the issue description yourself?
- endorphine 8小时前Really.. I was scrolling to find a comment complaining for this slop GH issue, which should be 10% of the size of what it is.
Surprised me it took so much scrolling to get to this.
Like, who reads all that crap?
- majorbugger 8小时前Yeah nah it's yet another security risk. There was an article recently about Claude Code desktop installing some browser files, it wasn't a hole per-se but doesn't make the whole thing trustworthy.
- rtk_asp 10小时前"Sources for the load-bearing claims"
I no longer know if this is a real person who is simping for Anthropic and will be ultimately enslaved by Anthropic or if this is an Anthropic ad to have "proof" for the high demand of their services.
- applfanboysbgon 9小时前Neither, it is just a random LLM-generated issue.
- make3 4小时前This won't fit everyone of course, but I've found that the Cursor / VScode extension of Claude is similar (though not perfect) to the desktop client. It's kind of like letting Microsoft deal with the Electron variability stuff in a way.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 10小时前I love the dueling messages on AI
"It'll make software easy and replace all software jobs!"
"Sorry, a Linux client is too hard and too much work!"
- pixl97 7小时前Interesting take away, but one that I'd think is intrinsically wrong.
The Linux desktop is fragmented and gatekept in such a manner that most people of a reasonable mind aren't going to waste tokens on it, and damned sure not going to waste software/support engineer time on it.
Note that none of these complaints are about CLI or server software. "Linux" the kernel + GNU utils + shell handle all of this just fine. The year of the Linux desktop is just never going to happen unless one desktop standard takes over and 'wins' in the short to medium term.
Now, in the longer term when tokens run cheap maybe we'll successfully have 20 different competing, incompatible Linux deskstops, but it doesn't seem likely.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 3小时前Meh. Don't package it then. They could start by releasing source. The Linux community might be fragmented but they're also good at packaging software!
- BlueBerry2001 5小时前So true
- dahkenangnon 13小时前We are all waiting for it.
- trumpdong 10小时前Doesn't Wayland make it impossible anyway?
- giorgioz 6小时前Come on Linux is the terminal dominion for excellence! Claude Code in terminal all the way!!
- dstnn 11小时前You're better off just using code cli
- coretx 12小时前Why dont you ask Claude to write you a TUI ?
- DaveZale 5小时前and make it free so we're not paying to be beta testers ;-)
- cyanydeez 12小时前Why would they do that with their...checks notes...software changing AI?
- gaiagraphia 11小时前Anthropic one-shotting a Linux distro would be quite the ad...
Perplexity are devleoping Comet as an AI-powered browser. I wonder if anybody will take the OS leap.
- JohnHaugeland 12小时前just use WINE or docker
- syllogistic 12小时前> Just use WINE
Did you just tell me to go fuck myself ?
- xdavidliu 12小时前pull requests are welcome
- LoganDark 8小时前"Linux" is not an operating system. One does not "just" release something "for Linux"
- the__alchemist 7小时前Inded. But... Let's say by compiling for Windows and MacOS you are making it work on 80% of users' computers. Then you compile on an older Ubuntu version which will work on any newer Ubuntu or Debian system, and you're at 90%. Worth doing. Then you do a Centos/RH build to get to 95%.
This won't work for all Linux users, but that doesn't have to be the bar. Making a few linux builds for the most popular distros is incrementally better than saying it's Windows/Mac only.
- shevy-java 10小时前Please don't.
There is already way too much slop.
- knightops_dev 9小时前[flagged]
- claudiosilva 5小时前[flagged]
- d1553636d 7小时前[flagged]
- znpy 12小时前That will come the year after the year of linux on. The desktop /s
Can confirm. At a past company we worked hard to release a Linux desktop client for our customers who wanted it, even though the number was small.
It turns into compatibility hell very fast. You think you can target a couple recent Ubuntu releases and everything will be good, but then you’re getting peppered with complaints from people using distributions you’ve never heard of because some part of the app isn’t working right. So your engineers spend a half day installing that in a VM and debugging it, but the problem is in upstream somewhere. The number of tickets with Linux issues keeps growing and each one is taking more time to debug, all for a number of customers that is so small you can’t justify doing it.
But those customers are angry. And vocal. They’re posting all over Twitter, Hacker News, and Reddit about how your company’s software is garbage, without mentioning that they’re running an unknown distribution on a 13 year old ThinkPad.
This even impacts open source projects. Several popular OSS Electron apps don’t work on many popular distros unless you set some command line workarounds, and even then it’s flakey. The open source projects get a pass because it’s open source, but if your company releases something you might be picking up a lot of angry, vocal customers that you didn’t want.
A lot of that is keyboard shortcuts for push-to-talk. Easy right?
X11 is mostly fine, but the world is moving into Wayland. Wayland doesn't have shortcuts native and relies on xdg-desktop-portal, which in turn relies on each backend to implement it's own version.
COSMIC from the Pop!OS team's xdg-desktop-cosmic doesn't support GlobalShortcuts yet (might now, haven't checked in a bit). So XWayland for them.
Tray icons? GNOME doesn't have a tray out of the box, but there's an extension. There's no standard for whether it's light mode or dark mode across distros and when you map out the options, no api's indicate whether the tray is light or dark while in light/dark mode. At some point you have to just accept it's not always perfect or patch in an override.
Global shortcuts definitely a pain point with Wayland but the portals are making progress.
While GNOME tray lovers and haters both exist, only one of those two groups is liable to submit an issue against my repo looking for help getting icons working correctly.
A lot of us = very few people in total, apparently.
There's a reason Dash to Dock and AppIndicator are packaged by default on most Gnome distros and overwhelmingly installed on those that don't have it. Even Gnome itself has started development on a native systray, although in classic Gnome NIH fashion they either want to implement a new standard or are were even considering using the deprecated snixembed standard instead of using what 99% of Linux does :+)
(Technically they want it for pretty good reasons, but good luck forcing all Linux applications to implement yet another standard, especially the commercial applications)
Back when I still had a need for it it was solely because some apps do not have proper support for missing tray icons (you can only fully close them via the tray icon), not because I actually like the feature.
I appreciate that GNOME tries to move on from this. Unfortunately it doesn't have the market control that Windows has, so not all app developers follow suit.
All these issues can happen in any platform, Linux is just the more annoying/unpredictable one, with GNOME taking the cake for being so obtuse. There is either a carelessness from the developer or the ad-hoc nature of those "tray icon" systems is to blame.
KDE Plasma allows hide selected applications from the tray and make those accessible in a popup window. The solution to this problem is not to remove the feature entirely, but actually implement it properly.
The lack of desktop UI affordances in the leading "user-friendly" Linux distribution should be seen as a five-alarm fire by anyone interested in promoting wider Linux acceptance on the desktop. There are reasons why Linux can't get past low single-digit adoption no matter how badly Apple and Microsoft screw their users, and I'm sure the half-assed desktop UI is one of them.
On GNOME? Alt-tab, super overview, or click the dock icon. It's literally not any more complex than multitasking on an iPad.
That point would hold some water if the iPad were intended as a first-class multitasking platform, like a desktop OS. I don't know what the 'super' key in GNOME is, and don't much care, because if that kind of thing isn't obvious it might as well not exist. Having never used *nix on a graphical desktop before, I'm just blown away by how primitive the experience is.
Fortunately Claude Code was happy to install dash-to-panel for me when I asked it what the deal was with this particular flavor of airline food.
This is like having someone tell you that they refuse to use an iPad because the home button confuses them. That's your choice.
I've used GNOME professionally for 7 years now, and I've taught kids to use it at robotics workshops. If you can believe it, many of them are unable to use macOS and Windows at all, because their school districts don't buy them laptops anymore. I'm sorry that GNOME isn't a carbon copy of your favorite OS, but it's not hard to use whatsoever.
Or just linux?
I think the latter. And it might surprise you, but there are computers with no linux installed. I think the vast majority actually. So why the need for insults?
I used some sort of *nix on a VAX terminal in college and ran SUSE on my machine once I realized I hated Windows 98 but all of that is ancient history at this point lol. All of that is to say that it is possible for someone to be peripherally interested in this topic and not be aware of what a super key would be even in context. Maybe someone that uses Windows could pick up on it earlier but I certainly didn’t:)
Guess what, I also only learned recently (some years now I think) after making it mire default, that on linux the windows key is called super key. And the person you insulted clarified he did not use linux at all.
So, how should he have known, despite working with computer extensivly?
I'm extremely experienced using and developing for Windows (and earlier) platforms, but it's true that I've never used a Linux machine before. I'm taking the opportunity to deliberately set one up and use it with Claude Code's help, in order to understand where the remaining sharp edges are, as well as the remaining dull ones. Desktop UX definitely qualifies as one of the latter.
Key point is that I don't want to press any keys to maintain my awareness of what's running on the machine. Processes with windows associated with them should always be apparent in one way or another. Ubuntu got the less-useful part of the taskbar right -- the quick-launch icons on the column at left -- while failing to do the important thing, which is to show, well, tasks.
I remember when they first started putting Windows keys on keyboards. If you think AI pisses people off, LOL... you weren't reading Slashdot and other Linux-adjacent sites when those keys started showing up. It's amusing to see that they've been embraced (if not extended) by the haters.
You have taken on the work the distributions do in the open source world. No upstream open source developer takes that on. Instead of getting bug reports from users, upstream developers insist bug reports are filtered by the distro maintainer first. They fix problems on their side so you never see them, and the ones that do make it through have been triaged. It's a win for everyone.
So the solution is to handle it the way they do. Choose a couple of baselines: maybe Debian Stable and Fedora. Publish packages for them, and make it plain they are only certified for those platforms. Make the rest someone else's problem: if you want it working on distro X, you package it for distro X. You've done the bulk of the work for them anyway, as most of them are either Debian or RPM based.
There are companies that do this right. But it often requires a hire. Too many companies think they can just yolo it because Linux isn’t a serious OS or whatever and then are surprised when it doesn’t work out well.
That's often a great idea!
But a full time hire? The GP's post implies that wouldn't make business sense for them, as even half a day occasionally on it is too much...
>> So your engineers spend a half day installing that in a VM and debugging it, but the problem is in upstream somewhere. The number of tickets with Linux issues keeps growing and each one is taking more time to debug, all for a number of customers that is so small you can’t justify doing it.
Of course an experienced Linux release engineer can do it faster and more reliably. That's probably the cheaper option. But the business still has to decide their Linux customer or user base is large enough, or strategically worth supporting, to justify the cost however they do it.
For many businesses even fractional Linux support is not justifiable for the small number of Linux users and support requests they're unable to handle. Though I can't imagine that being the case for Anthropic!
(Hint: This is one of the things I consult on, if anyone is looking to pay for quality Linux release engineering and platform testing. I have hundreds of historical and current Linux VMs, multiple architectures old and new (esp. x86, ARM and RISC-V), some of them embedded, fairly deep knowledge of how the kernel and libraries work together, and test harnesses. Also I test some compiled applications for portability across other OSes and architectures, including Windows, MS-DOS, MacOS, BSDs, SunOS, HP-UX, etc. going all the way back to the early Unix lineage.)
I agree that sticking to libc is most reliable, if you can. But the experience is poor if you do that for desktop applications.
There's no singular source of truth, but there's a de facto frontier of only a few mainstream distros, as well as upstream heads for your dependencies.
It's extra work, but there are systematic workarounds to the feature drift over time and the tendancy of some open source projects to aggressively deprecate older functionality and older system compatilbilty.
You can, to an extent, automate testing on newer versions of distros to be alerted when something no longer works, and often you can do this before the official distro release date.
Unfortunately even libc is not reliable. Unless it's a static build, Glibc is often broken (with symbol version errors) when trying to run a binary compiled on one distro on another distro, or an older version of the same distro. Static binaries have other problems, though work very well if the application is self contained and isn't a GUI.
One thing that I find works very compatibly, though, is OpenGL / Vulkan binary-compatibility across distros and versions. There was a lot of work done on making libGL something you can link to or dynamically load reliably and take it from there. The OpenGL extension spaghetti is an interesting problem from then on, but that's more to do with the individual user's GPU and GPU drivers, independent of the Linux distro or even which OS it's running on.
Not if they're GPL licensed you can't. And that's a headache most commercial people do not want at all when trying to write software that's often for a marginal part of their audience anyway.
Wrong, misleading and possibly FUD. Yes you can ship GPL licensed software with your application, even a proprietary, closed source application.
You have to comply with the GPL terms, but that's easy to do for every library or auxiliary program that you'd link to or call in a Linux distro.
The GPL is designed to support this use case, with it's "mere aggregation" clause making it clear that it's allowed.
The one thing you can't do if you're shipping a closed source application is link to GPL-licensed code (unless there's an special exception clause, or it's LGPL, or it's dual-licensed to allow this). But for this type of GPL library, you can't use the Linux distro's shipped version either. So the GPL constraint makes no difference to the question of whether you can ship a frozen or fallback version with your application in lieu of the distro version.
If there's a corner case the above doesn't cover, I'm not aware of it and I've studied GPL compliance more thoroughly than most people. So I'd like to know about it :-)
I dunno why this is always so difficult.
My reply to the comment below outlines the shape of the problem.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48434436#48435801
But it has proven quite the challenge to support old Linux distros. We have tried using nix to pin deps, but this easily leads to new issues: hardcoded RPATHs leaking into binaries, glibc compatibility issues, etc.
If we instead fork the build environment and use an old Ubuntu for building our Linux app, then my life gets harder, because now I have two targets for a whole lot of internal tooling that my team maintains, and that tooling needs to be deployed to both build environments. Again, its the same shit: glibc mismatches, missing/different shared libraries, etc. Just causing problems in a different place.
There is certainly some element of skill issue at play. But I wouldn't call it easy.
I have recently been working on a C11 GTK+ based task manager where I run into this. https://github.com/hparadiz/evemon/tree/main/packaging
This is why I said bundle your libs. If you bundle ALL of your libs you can't possibly run into an issue if your install script is run as root. Unless it's an extremely eccentric non desktop oriented system at which point that's kind of on them.
If you wanna cover 99.9% of Linux you build fedora, ubuntu, debian, nixos, arch and have a tar.gz as your overflow. For each target the lowest available LTS and don't waste time on distros that aren't getting security updates. It's not reasonable to ask for binaries built against your specific 11 year old gcc.
edit wanted to add one more thing.
I'm a big believer in having your tar.gz and install script inform your deb, rpm, aur, etc. It should be basically the same exact thing as your tar.gz just done in the format those distros want.
Flatpak can be set up on many/most distros.
- titlebar
- tray icon w/light and dark mode support
- global keyboard shortcut
- redraw events after resizing
Those are a subset of the many items that don't play well between various distros.
Like Ubuntu Gnome w/X11 vs Pop!OS COSMIC w/Wayland or any of the tiling window managers like hyprland.
Obviously this will probably fail on other distros, but I've found in the past similar groupings. Backwards compatibility is different: I expect a package a compile on Ubuntu 24 not to work on Ubuntu 22.
This is anecdotal, and in the context of rust + EGUI, so I'm not sure how applicable it is to Electron.
I recently hit a Wayland snag: It doesn't support Device Events other than mouse movement. I worked around it by changing to Window events. I could see that being annoying if this substitution weren't acceptable, but it was in this case.
So get to grips with "upstream"! Managing upset "opinionated" and "entitled" users is par for the course anywhere. Have a look at how Veeam do it, for example.
Obviously that sort of compatibility nonsense never happens in say Windows (fairly popular OS).
Let's take a quick look at say web proxies. Proxies are quite popular in corporate environments but blow me if Windows and vendors who use it make it as hard as possible to deal with:
You might think group policy would sort it all out - lol! You have loads of elderly policies relating to IE (several versions) hanging around smelling rather fishy and mildly useful if you have older Windows hanging around. You can use GPOs to fix the following but it will be Preferences and involve a bit of ingenuity.
You have .Net Framework apps - eg AD Sync (Entra, Smentra whatever its called today). That will need you to fiddle with a specific XML file.
winhttp api? Powershell. OK you have two sets of settings here: proxy and advproxy. proxy has string properties that you set and is a bit crap and advproxy has a JSON flavour and is a bit shit. advproxy seems to ignore anything in the ignore list apart from or exclusively <local>. At least advproxy allows you to fall back on a proxy.pac file (which IE decided to call wpad.dat and who can forget an IE5 version that called it WPAD.DA?)
Picking on Linux users is disingenuous - all OSs can be customized to the point of tricky to support and besides who on earth is Twitter?
Much easier to create a vm testing swarm of 100 disitributions with llms
"Tony Stark can do it in a cave! With rocks!"
:)
It’s not a great experience if only some apps on supported on your favourite Linux distro while others aren’t.
Sure, you'll still get a few complaints from ideological purists, but there's no avoiding that regardless of what you do.
These angry customers are a symptom of having more customers; in this direction (compatibility) companies shouldn't be KPI'ing on angry customers.
It is very legitimate that high compatibility means more very obscure, low value, high cost, bug reports that are hard to classify as such. And my gosh, I hate working with rude ticket writers.
No, it's a symptom of having more of a very specific type of customer who is more demanding and difficult to please than your other customers.
When you don't officially support Linux, the Linux users are not surprised. It's normal for them. They find other ways to use the product.
When you do announce Linux support, you open Pandora's box of complaints. They're extra angry that you claim Linux support but it doesn't work perfectly on their unique combination of laptop, distro, display protocol, and window manager.
You gained a small number of happy customers, but picked up a disproportionately large number of angry, vocal customers in the process.
I wasn't looking to anger you, just to provide a different lens in which to view the situation.
Flatpak serves a need, there are plenty of users who like it and there are probably even more who just use it without thinking much about it. Personally, I like it for a few reasons: - Being able to install something dependency-heavy with just one package - Sandboxing - Getting a newer package than what my distro provides - Being able to update apps independently of the rest of the OS - Being able to easily install apps that my distro doesn't provide
The people who hate it, especially without giving a reason, are largely irrelevant when flatpak is filling a need for so many other people. Design for the people who are using and who like your product. Make adjustments based on their feedback. Ignore the people who just make noise.
And how do you know the userbase for GP's specific product is all Flatpak users? In fact, based on their comment, it appears as though they are explicitly not, hence their vocal frustration.
Ultimately if something isn't in my distro's repository, i try to compile it from source and if that isn't available, i just use something else.
Made comment about flatpack below the comment above.
But they do? Companies don’t publish anything BUT electron apps. If desktop Linux gets anything from outside of FOSS, it’s electron. See Spotify, discord, slack, vscode… list goes on. I don’t think a for profit company has provided a GTK or qt app for Linux in the last 20 years.
I applaud your efforts but this is a supposed trillion dollar company with a product that probably has thousands of electron apps in its training set. They should be paying you.
The comment was that the Electron apps aren’t being released for Linux even when they exist because Linux is so much harder to support, even in Electron.
If they don’t have resources (or desire) to keep the Electron app working on all the Linux distros then they definitely won’t have the resources to write a completely separate GTK app for the few Linux users.
Have you considered that maybe their code is just bad?
If your app is open source, I say just build & test on one of the major distros and let the community port it to others. If its closed source, well, good luck. But if what the parent said is true, that you now collect a bunch of very vocal pissed off customers because you didn't support their favorite distro, then its just not worth it at the current marketshare that desktop Linux has.
There's also the challenge of you just can't make any assumptions about what may be present or not on someone's Linux machine, even with the major distros.
I personally think they should port it, but, the developer product does already run on Linux, in the terminal, as is the case with the majority of other dev tools.
DaVinci resolve is QT. But making a video editor performant in Electron is even harder than writing it in C++..
After going through this process to get codex installed on Linux I'm honestly baffled why OpenAI doesn't have an official port. Though I haven't tested every part of the app, everything works as intended, even got computer use working without any issues.
I’m pretty sure that excludes Claude Desktop.
https://www.techtimes.com/articles/317463/20260531/flathub-a...
Swipe keyboards on mobile are awful, but I can't break that habit.
We haven’t.
Also, I can't break the swipe keyboard habit either. It's the worst, but still better than the alternatives. Someday I hope physical keyboard makes a return (but I"m not holding my breath)
It's great that I can ship one item for all platforms, but Flatpack doesn't solve the compatibility discovery problem for me.
More context in my reply to the comment linked here :https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48434436#48435661
Unfortunately they do, instead of implementing a proper native application (don't hire web developers to do native apps).
Look at e.g. Cisco Webex, or Telegram. You can make a proper native application that just works and is not electron. A lot of people don't like electron apps, and it is more important in current economy (memory prices are too high to invest in more RAM).
Apparently Linus Torvalds liked AppImage too.
https://archive.ph/PSqlB
flatpak!
The issue is folks expect this to be at a higher level, so when libc or GTK or Qt etc. have breaking changes, all your apps using the old versions fail. This is a legitimate pain point with traditional distros.. I don't want to sound like I'm downplaying it.
However, this is basically solved by flatpak (and others like it, eg snap) which contain _all_ these dependencies in the package. Layering (ala containers) is used for deduplication so you don't have 20 copies of a given GTK version.
While MacOS provides the windowing toolkit etc. at the OS level, it's otherwise similar to how a .app file works. Installers aren't dropping dynamic libraries and resource files all over your disk, the app is "self-contained."
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=48434436#48435801
The only proprietary software I have running on my machine is electron apps, which are essentially bloated VMs. As we’ve seen from this thread, this is still apparently too great of an engineering feat for anthropic to tackle. I don’t think I’m unique in this regard.
Of course a lot of Linux users these days just live their lives through browsers. That's pretty sad.
Teams: Was electron
Steam: Valve is deeply invested in Linux, this isn't them just shipping an app. Different category.
Jetbrains: Java
Cursor: Electron
Discord: Electron
Matlab: Java
ABI compatibility doesn't matter for any of your examples.
That said, an official build would make a huge difference for enterprise adoption. Many companies have policies against unofficial packages, and the signing + update mechanism is always going to be more trustworthy when it comes from Anthropic directly.
For anyone waiting: the unofficial build is perfectly usable for personal projects. But I would love to see Anthropic prioritize this -- the Linux developer community is exactly the audience that pushes Claude the hardest.
I'll be happy the day there's an official distribution and I can put the repo to rest
Of course, it's impossible to know for sure what was LLM processed or not, but most of your posts are getting classified that way.
You obviously have good points to make and are welcome here! but if you'd please write text by hand which you plan to post to HN itself, we'd appreciate it. The community feels strongly about this right now.
a) be welcoming and indicate that we're OK with broken English (content and intent typically do get through), and/or
b) allow posting in languages other than English (does this even work right now?).
Above probably ahead of its time, but thought I'd just make the suggestion.