6 条评论

• sysguru2046 1小时前
  I cloned your Spec-Driven-Development repo to my GitHub repo, use codex to generate a scraper checkpoint manager spec, then use codex prompt to implement the checkpoint logic. The new implementation has significant improvement on top of my original shape of checkpoint logic. It's strict implementation based on generated spec.
• bilbo-b-baggins 13小时前
  Look at the juxt/allium plugin. It’s a more mature version of what you’re attempting.

  Also big requirements/tasks files will rot your context opening up hallucinations and drift. So I’d guess your starting point isn’t useful for larger codebases.

  [-]
  • _blk 11小时前
    Wondering if this is attempting what github.com/gsd-build/get-shit-done has done: plan your milestones, discuss them, execute them, review them. It can also review the plans by another agent before execution... Everything documented and checked in.
• jfim 18小时前
  Sure, I'll take a stab at it, that looks interesting. I'll give you an update in a couple of hours.
  [-]
  • jfim 17小时前
    Still trying it out, but here's my feedback so far:

    - Overall the approach is sound, to generate various levels of documents from requirements to finer grained ones

    - I'm not sure if that's intended, but I got asked about four questions and then the model one shot all three documents at once, ideally you'd work on one at a time, then once you're happy generate the next level of documents

    - The prompting by the model was very shallow, it didn't ask enough questions so the requirements were off. I was expecting more questions so that the model had more information to work with. The docs can be iteratively reworked but I think it should make a better effort at the first take.

    - I don't think there's any versioning of documents but that would be useful

    - Dispatching subagents to review the generated plans would be nice

    Overall it's pretty reasonable, I can see it being pretty useful. Send me an email if you need more details.
• v1b3c0d3r 10小时前
  Have signed up for your testing pool. I think I fall under the non-technical vibe coder #2.
• aicodeprompts 11小时前
  [flagged]
• daohieu91 14小时前
  [dead]